top of page

Pie Crust Promise

"That's a pie crust promise - easily made, easily broken." ~ Mary Poppins

So I made my resolution to post every Sunday. . . maybe every other Sunday?


I'm missing La Madeleine in this real winter that Nashville is having.

No, not a person, but a place with memories:

  • Lunches with my high school boyfriend's mother over quiche and tomato basil soup.

  • Catching up with Jodi when back in Bethesda over croissants and potato galettes.

  • Grading papers on a school night by their fire and snacking on bread and jam.

For some reason, I was never self-conscious eating and sitting there alone for hours on end.

For some reason, I feel that way at a patisserie in Brooklyn too - where I always ordered a quiche and sat outside before I headed to Matt's brownstone.

Maybe the French believe food is too important not to miss a meal - solo or not. . .


I'm at a loss why we don't have one here; I've written them five times and begged - BEGGED.


So. . . as I planned to make a quiche for the week, I realized I have found a favorite crust recipe and haven't posted it here. Full credit goes to Baking Mischief.


This summer, I did a taste test of about four crust recipes for tomato tarts, plum tarts, and chicken pot pies.

Hers is the HANDS DOWN winner.


I would have been totally skeptical of the crumby mixture and squeeze together method if I hadn't seen Gesine do it on Baked in Vermont one day (my eyes bulging and head shaking as I watched.)


But they are both right: it works. And I love rolling the dough out after chilling and still seeing flecks of butter in the dough - it means the pockets will steam and crisp the crust.


The below is for two 9 inch crusts:

  • 2 1/2 cups flour

  • 1 T sugar

  • 1 tsp. salt

  • 1 cup (2 sticks) of frozen butter

  • 2/3 cup buttermilk

~ Pulse the flour, sugar, and salt in food processor.

~ Chop the frozen butter into cubes.

~ Add butter to flour mixture and pulse until flour has pea-sized crumbles.

~ Through the pour tube, slowly add the buttermilk while processing.

~ When the dough JUST forms (I wait till it tumbles once) STOP.

~ The dough will still SEEM dry and crumbly.

~ Divide dough on two long sheets of plastic wrap.

~ Press crumbs together using the plastic wrap to guard your hands.

(Warm hands mean melting the butter!)

~ Chill for thirty minutes before rolling out OR freeze and take out the night before you want to use.

I never have buttermilk in the house. Who does?

I've made it with milk and lemon juice, but so often I don't have lemons either.

So when I DO have buttermilk - I make several crusts and put several in the freezer.

We pulled six out at Christmas for pies!


A little gallery of how I've used it this year:

A plum galette, chicken pot pie and chicken pot hand pie, tomato pie, and cheeseburger pie.




Comments


FAVORITE THINGS

Frankie's Olive Oil

Williams Sonoma Croissants

Joe's Stone Crab Claws

bottom of page